
(Note: Essay contains spoilers)
It is the summer of 1994 and newly released from a stint at New York’s largest and most notorious prison, Rikers Island, convicted thief and hairdresser, Inez de la Paz (Teyana Taylor) returns to the streets of Brooklyn to rescue her six-year-old son, Terry (Aaron Kingsley Adetola), from the same foster care system that raised her. Through a daring act of abduction, Inez steals Terry away from the hospital after his botched attempt to escape the foster facility, and the two flee to the once Black Mecca of America, Harlem, where she will spend the next decade fighting tooth and nail to give him the one thing she never had — a home. In a March 2023 interview on the heels of the wide release of her Black melodrama, A Thousand and One, director A.V. Rockwell sat down with fellow Sundance winner Chinonye Chukwu, the first Black woman to receive the Grand Jury Prize in 2019 with her death row drama Clemency, for an interview with Filmmaker Magazine. Rockwell, a native of New York City, unpacks the challenge of her feature debut, “How do I feel about a city that I love so deeply, but it seems like it doesn’t really love me? This place that’s supposed to be a part of my DNA, how do I reconcile the fact that it doesn’t even want my people here and, looking back through history, probably never has?” In her 1992 essay, “The Oppositional Gaze: Black Female Spectators,” writer and cultural theorist bell hooks, laments a lifelong, unrequited love affair with film, “Mainstream feminist film criticism in no way acknowledges Black female spectatorship. It does not even consider the possibility that women can construct an oppositional gaze via an understanding and awareness of the politics of race and racism” (hooks 123). Through interrogation, hooks takes to task film criticism’s suppression of race while reenacting and mirroring the erasure of Black womanhood that occurs on screen. “Every black woman spectator I talked to, with rare exception, spoke of being ‘on guard’ at the movies” (hooks 126). Thirty years later, Rockwell speaks to this pain as both a spectator and a director, “If they weren’t going to honor us, I wanted to do that in my own way—not just African American women, but underprivileged Black women, especially, because I do think they have the hardest fight.” How does one situate the Black home in an environment that seeks to destabilize all attempts at longevity? The political stakes of Rockwell’s One Thousand and One lay in the recuperation of images of poor Black women on screen as much as in affirming the pleasure of Black women’s spectatorship in a city that harbors nothing by ire for their very existence.
In lieu of dignified depictions of themselves on screen, poor Black women in the United States have had to contend with a prevalence of racist caricatures in film, politics, and news media. During a January 1976 campaign rally, former California governor Ronald Reagan breathed life into the infamous stereotype and boogeywoman of American politics — the welfare queen. “In Chicago, they found a woman who holds the record. She used 80 names, 30 addresses, 15 telephone numbers to collect food stamps, Social Security, veterans’ benefits for four nonexistent deceased veteran husbands, as well as welfare. Her tax-free cash income alone has been running $150,000 a year.” This sensational portrayal became a hallmark of Reagan’s campaign as he would go on to enthusiastically preach the financial evils of women from the South Side of Chicago. Keen observers latched onto the racial dog whistling as the future 40th President of the United States sought to place the nation’s economic strains on the shoulders of low-income women whose greed, according to him, ran so far from the purview of acceptable norms that it had become a crisis on the federal scale. One has to wonder where this rallying spirit was during his term as Commander-in-Chief when Washington’s apathy watched silently as the HIV/AIDs epidemic laid waste to millions of American lives. Twenty years later, Reagan’s Democratic rival and 42nd President, Bill Clinton, signed the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996 (P.L. 104-193). The bill was authored by the now 46th President of the United States, Joe Biden, and received resounding bipartisan support. At the signing ceremony, President Clinton proclaimed, “Today, we are ending welfare as we know it…. The two parties cannot attack each other over it. Politicians cannot attack poor people over it. . . . This is not the end of welfare reform, this is the beginning. And we have to all assume responsibility.” His declaration left critics scratching their heads. Many viewed the shift as a convenient scapegoat for economic woes and a means of Democrats demonstrating to their base that they could be just as tough as their Republican counterparts. American writer, attorney, and civil rights activist Michelle Alexander traces the replacement of Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) with a block grant to states called Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF) in her formative text The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness.
“By 1996, the penal budget doubled the amount that had been allocated to AFDC or food stamps. Similarly, funding that had once been used for public housing was being redirected to prison construction. During Clinton’s tenure, Washington slashed funding for public housing by $17 billion (a reduction of 61 percent) and boosted corrections by $19 billion (an increase of 171 percent), effectively making the construction of prisons the nation’s main housing program for the urban poor” (Alexander 57).
Rockwell’s Black female subject exists in the wake of these policy shifts while also finding herself in the political crosshairs of New York City mayors Rudy Guiliani and Michael Bloomberg between 1994 and 2005. Despite their seemingly oppositional visions for revitalizing the city at the dawn of the 21st century, their respective policies enact a united disdain for Inez, Terry, and all native Harlemites. Guiliani’s tenure comes to represent administrative neglect and judicial harassment, while Bloomberg’s tenure signals a mass displacement of natives through gentrification under the ironic banner of progressive inclusion and reform. Early on, struggling to find employment, Inez balks at the suggestion of taking janitorial work in Jamaica Queens as it will require two hours in transit back and forth. She will eventually accept the position but not before Miss Annie (Adriane Lenox), who opens her home to Inez and Terry, chastises her lack of resolve, “Your generation don’t know just how good you have it.” The scene transitions to street-level shots overlaid with audio from then-Mayor Guiliani announcing a crackdown on jaywalking a policy that will disproportionately affect Black and brown residents leading to even higher levels of criminalization for pedestrians. Later on, audio of Mayor Bloomberg’s inaugural address, “As the 108th mayor of the city of New York. As Toni Morrison has said, ‘New York is the last true city.’ And it is the vitality of our neighborhoods that defines us. In the next four years, I will devote myself to building a better New York. Safe, strong, and ready to lead the world in the 21st century. Thank you.” The audio is juxtaposed with footage of corporate outlets— Old Navy, T-Mobile, Chuck E. Cheese, followed immediately by a shot of a nondescript building’s demolition making priorities clear— out with the old, in with the new.
If there is to be any doubt about cross-party solidarity, Rockwell shows a devastating moment of thirteen-year-old Terry at the intersection between both administration’s policies when he arrives at the neighborhood laundromat to find the business sold with their doors closed for good. Turning around, he is swarmed by NYPD officers who shove him up against the wall, hands held behind his back, in what is known as a ‘routine stop-and-frisk.’ Once their body search is complete, the officers apologize for assuming Terry to be an adult. At this moment, it becomes clear that his name is no mere coincidence. Terry comes to represent generations of Black individuals stripped of their autonomy, for this sort of warrantless search was once deemed unconstitutional under the Fourth Amendment until the decision of Terry v Ohio in 1968 which ruled that an officer “is entitled for the protection of himself and others in the area to conduct a limited search to discover weapons that might be used against the officer.” Michelle Alexander addresses this judicial shift, “Known as the stop-and-frisk rule, the Terry decision stands for the proposition that, so long as a police officer has ‘reasonable articulable suspicion’ that someone is engaged in criminal activity and dangerous, it is constitutionally permissible to stop, question and frisk him or her— even in the absence of probable cause” (Alexander 63).
While Rockwell’s narrative portrays an almost seamless transition between mayors, her film’s grammar does much to distinguish the eras through color saturation in line with each mayor’s party affiliation. The Guiliani years are shown in fiery, earthy red tones. The images don’t shy away from the deteriorating architecture, nor the poverty but there is a celebration of the richness and vitality of a community. Around the hour mark as the film jumps to the year 2001 the frame is bathed in dark sapphire blues. Interiors and exteriors become cold and sterile as redevelopment washes over Harlem leaving many houseless. “I wanted to tell a story about a family versus the city. I was trying to understand what happened to New York City as I knew it, and what was happening to communities of color that felt targeted—trying to tell that story but also parallel it against what my experiences have been or experiences other Black women have [had] coming of age in this environment,” said Rockwell of her experience.
At the film’s onset, twenty-two-year-old Inez de la Paz is a difficult woman to love. Her criminal record, her gender and skin tone, along with her houseless status have done much to diminish her character in the eyes of society. During their race to Harlem to evade the reach of social services and law enforcement, Inez stands on a street corner outside a phone booth in the middle of the night desperate to find shelter when she takes Terry’s hands in hers, she promises, “I’ll go to war for you. Do you understand that? Against anybody. Against this whole fucked-up city. They can try all they want. They can try all they want but they not breaking us up this time. You want to find a new home? Hmm?” That night they are offered a brief shelter in the Harlem brownstone owned by Inez’s best friend Kim’s mother, Mrs. Jones (Delissa Reynolds). The surname undoubtedly alludes to “Keeping up with the Joneses,” a popular 20th-century idiom originating in the comic strip of the same name, created by Arthur R. “Pop” Momand in 1913. The phrase was popularized as a marker of socio-economic material success with the obvious burden of stress placed upon those who failed to keep up. Mrs. Jones operates as an emblem of Black respectability, harboring deep suspicion and scorn toward Inez often offering unsolicited criticism. When her daughter’s friend arrives on her doorstep houseless and penniless, she asks if it is ‘Ghetto Inez’ and then refuses to greet them. Later she tells Inez, “You can’t go to anybody’s place looking and talking like that.” Even when Inez can secure work, Mrs. Jones derides her lack of motherly attention telling Terry that when she was little, her mother took the time to teach her to read, implying that her mother had the privilege to spend so much time with her children. This judgment is later corrupted by a scene with Inez reading to Terry but not before tensions become untenable when Inez succumbs to her taunts and becomes physical. The two find themselves houseless once more.
In the introduction to Home is Where the Heart Is: Studies in Melodrama and the Woman’s Film, Christine Gledhill states, “Despite the current association of melodrama with the domestic, it could be created out of almost any topic. Nevertheless melodramas invariable deployment of familial values across sub-genres attests to a psychic overdetermination in the conjunction of social and personal, charging the idea of home and family with a symbolic potency” (Gledhill 21). An encouraging declaration no doubt but one wonders how a genre famously dedicated to the predicaments of white, often upwardly mobile women — which rarely finds ruptures wide enough to fit the presence of the Black mammy, in both adaptations of Imitation of Life (1934 & 1959), or a tortured mulatta in John Cassevetes’ Shadows (1959) — will configure itself around the emotional needs of a poor, dark-skinned woman and ex-convict struggling to avoid eviction in an era of gentrification and mass incarceration. Rockwell’s film roots itself in these concerns and they are addressed in the film’s opening sequence when Inez, still incarcerated in Rikers Island, does the hair and make-up of a fellow inmate, also a Black woman. Before she begins Inez must position her subject as Rockwell positions her audience. She tenderly looks over the unnamed Black woman’s hair and face then takes the seat in front of her where their gaze aligns thus signaling a mutual recognition of humanity in both women. Rockwell communicates directly with her Black female spectators— hold your head up high. This is a reaffirming gaze where your stories are handled with the dignity and complexity they deserve. Later, this is further conveyed in Harlem with the reaction of a Black woman from the neighborhood admiring herself in the mirror once Inez finishes her hair. Almost at a loss for words, she remarks “Girl, I feel like something.” Rockwell cultivates an environment where Black women, particularly those of low income, are treated with grace and afforded the space for their humanity to be acknowledged and to see themselves the way they want to be seen.
Rockwell’s film delves into the charged atmosphere of the Black home and Inez’s undying efforts to shield her family from the forces of white supremacist domination seeping in. She is unfettered by traditional markers and constraints of motherhood– blood, money, and legality. When her partner and former partner in crime, Lucky (William Catlett), fresh from a stint in prison asks her, “What do two crooks know about raising a family?” she replies, “Do you remember what it felt like to grow up without a father? I just want us to be a family.” In her essay, ‘Homeplace: A Site of Resistance’ bell hooks lends a critical recognition to much of the radical and unrecognized labor of Black mothers,
“Since sexism delegates to females the task of creating and sustaining a home environment, it has been primarily the responsibility of black women to construct domestic households as spaces of care and nurturance in the face of the brutal harsh reality of racist oppression, of sexist domination. Historically, African-American people believed that the construction of a homeplace, however fragile and tenuous (the slave hut, the wooden shack), had a radical political dimension. Despite the brutal reality of racial apartheid, of domination, one’s homeplace was the one site where one could freely confront the issue of humanization, where one could resist. Black women resisted by making homes where all black people could strive to be subjects, not objects, where we could be affirmed in our minds and hearts despite poverty, hardship, and deprivation, where we could restore to ourselves the dignity denied us on the outside in the public world.” (hooks 42)
Throughout the film, Inez is shown between work shifts, contributing a titanic amount of love into Unit 1001— from new coats of paint for his bedroom to taping Terry’s artwork on the wall, to nightly home-cooked meals, to purchasing books for Terry to read. She procures a counterfeit social security card for his doctor’s visits and later on prods him to apply for a specialty high school that will open him up to opportunities she never had. Unfortunately though not surprisingly, her sacrifices will go largely unacknowledged. Lucky becomes an on-again, off-again presence in her life, disappearing on a whim for months at a time when life at home becomes overwhelming. Coming of age for most of the film, Terry struggles to see his mother beyond his domestic expectations.
Class status will act as a constant divider throughout the film separating even Black women from each other. Mrs. Jones is none too thrilled with the prospect of hosting an ex-convict and single mother. As tensions flair, she walks away from an argument with Inez, telling her, “I don’t think anything of you,” before commenting that their presence is, “Turning my house into damn 125th Street.” Her daughter Kim (Terri Abney), the only friend Inez can turn to in her time of need, takes a softer approach though her line of inquiry speaks to a naivety to circumstance. As the two lay in her bed, Kim asks Inez if she was able to earn her GED. When Inez confirms that she obtained her degree while in prison, Kim enthusiastically cheers for her spurring a less than gracious response from Inez who tells her, “You always get excited about the weirdest things.” While this response can be attributed to Inez’s prickly demeanor, the boundaries surrounding her circumstance are made clear a moment later when Inez laments the lack of employment opportunities for hairstylists in Harlem and Kim flippantly suggests that Inez simply open her own shop as though it would manifest at the snap of her fingers. Inez asks her what she is supposed to do about money at that very moment, stating her immediate needs— food and shelter. Her limitations are further heightened by the police sirens playing in the background throughout their exchange. The film later introduces Mrs. Tucker, a light-skinned Black female social worker, whose repeated claims of working in Terry’s best interests are rendered dubious as she requires his cooperation with the same law enforcement apparatus that has demonstrated its antagonistic stance toward him and Inez for years. The accumulated weight of all that these women do not see in a poor, dark-skinned single mother with a criminal record amounts to the crux of the film’s contentions. During their confrontation, Inez tells Terry, “Nobody else give a shit about Black women except for other Black women, and even that shit get messy.”
Citing her early essay ‘Do you remember Saphire?’ hooks recounts her experience with onscreen negations of Black female representation, the shame and displeasure, and the turning away,
“She was even then backdrop, foil. She was bitch-nag. She was there to soften images of Black men, to make them seem vulnerable, easygoing, funny; and unthreatening to a white audience. She was there as man in drag, as castrating bitch, as someone to be lied to, someone to be tricked, someone the white and Black audience could hate. Scapegoated on all sides… We did not long for her. We did not want our construction to be this hated black female thing-foil, backdrop. Her black female image was not the body of desire. There was nothing to see. She was not us” (hooks 120).
The proliferation of images of the hardened, desexualized, and undesirable overbearing Black women saturate 20th-century American cinema while showing no signs of letting up in the 21st. From Tyler Perry’s long-running Madea franchise spanning over a dozen films to retro and contemporary mammy renditions in Precious (2009), The Help (2011), and The Butler (2013), to popular depictions of literal drag in the films of Eddie Murphy and Martin Lawrence such as Norbit (2007) and Big Momma’s House (2000) and Big Momma’s House 2 (2006), Black female spectators still contend with delegitimizing images of themselves. Rockwell says of her film, “What people that see the film understand by the end is that this was a story about a Black woman who was desperate to be loved, not just needed.”
While Rockwell demonstrates her ease at endowing her Black female subjects with care, Inez will spend the entirety of the film fighting for scraps of empathy from her son, her husband Lucky (William Catlett), her neighbors, landlords, and city hall. During an argument with her on-again, off-again partner Lucky, Inez speaks to this erasure,
Inez: Who gives a fuck about what [Terry/Darryl] wants? What does he need?
Lucky: You’re too tough. Maybe if you quiet down some, he would actually hear what you have to say.
Inez: I don’t even remember the last time I raised my voice. You used to like when I got spicy. [Taunts] You should try and be quiet. If I get any quieter I won’t have a fuckin’ voice at all… You get to be the saint while I’m stuck here fighting these wars all by myself.
Lucky: See how loud you’re getting?
Inez: Show up for me! I wonder what would happen if I leave too.
Rockwell is not content with merely presenting her subject as an innocent, put-upon victim and source of sentimentality for audiences to offer sympathy and little more. Over time, Inez is forced to look inward at her pattern of behavior and more importantly, why she feels she must keep up such a “strong” front. Alone again after her fight with Lucky, Inez dines on a cup of instant noodles with nothing but the glow of the television to light her space, signaling a lack of time and energy to look after herself once she has looked after everyone else. In another moment of onscreen spectatorship, the camera holds an extended close-up shot of Inez’s face as the audio from an episode of Ricki Lake’s talk show plays in the background. The segment features a Black couple talking through their issues and compromise. We hear an echo of Inez on stage in a Black woman who talks about losing friendship, saying, “Well, it has cost me a lot of friendships, and a lot of relationships, but I find in life that having a friend in yourself is better than worrying about having people as your friends, ‘cause no one’s gonna look out for you but you, and I’ve learned that in life. [audience applause] I’ve looked out for people you know, but– I mean, I’m saying, I have friends now. They’re bitchy like me, so we get along. I’m serious. We understand each other. And I help out with some of my family members as well as they help me.” Throughout this exchange, Inez’s expressions shift from tears to laughter to tears again as she sees herself in this woman and feels seen.

A driving force throughout A Thousand and One is the recuperation of the past. Being a product of the New York state foster system, Inez vows with all her might to keep Terry from the harm she incurred as a youth. In a news report, his shelter is referred to as “One of the city’s most troubled and underfunded hospitals.” Her motivations lay in providing Terry with a home, a family, and two loving parents. Unit 1001 becomes their home for a period, the stability of the marriage waxes and wanes, and eventually Terry must spread his wings out into the big world but through it all Inez remains as determined as when she began. Christine Gledhill identifies this melodramatic desire in her introduction, “This surfaces in a persistently nostalgic vein. As David Grimstead and Martha Vicinus note, melodrama’s challenge lies not in confronting how things are, but rather in asserting how they ought to be. But since it operates within the frameworks of the present social order, melodrama conceives ‘the promise of human life’” (Gledhill 21). It is accurate to say Rockwell’s film is as concerned with its present as its past, to such a degree that a tradition of displacement, loss, and longing is formed by the ending. On the eve of his high school graduation, social services uncover Terry/Darryl’s falsified birth certificate. The social worker Ms. Tucker (Amelia Workman) not only brings the police to their apartment but outs Inez as not Terry’s biological mother expressing false and cruel remorse, “I’m sorry you had to find out like this. I just want what’s best for you.” They tell him they have to remove him from her custody adding, “If that’s alright with you.” Catching Inez on the eve of her flight from law enforcement, Terry confronts her with this information only to learn that it was Inez who took him in after he was abandoned on a street corner at the age of two by his biological mother. He is thrown into a state of total dissolution as the news comes on the heels of Lucky’s passing from cancer and the revelation that before his death, Lucky fathered a child with another woman from the neighborhood behind Inez’s back. Unable to grapple with their impending separation, Inez’s deception, and what comes next, Terry retreats into the past, breaking down into tears and pleading, “‘Cause I’m scared. I’m scared that I won’t have no home no more. And one day I’m gonna show up and it’s gonna feel like we ain’t’ never happened. Ma! Like this wasn’t our living room, our home. I miss my bed, Ma. The one that you made for me. Where is home for me now?”
Ultimately, Rockwell’s film asks spectators irrespective of race how much empathy and grace they are willing to extend to a poor Black female ex-convict. How much of this woman are audiences willing to see? And should spectators find that humanity in Inez, how does one configure what is right and wrong? For Black women who see themselves in Inez, Rockwell imbues her subject with layers of contradiction, compassion, and a degree of existential autonomy rarely seen on screen. “Black female critical thinkers concerned with creating space for the construction of radical Black female subjectivity, and the way cultural production informs this possibility, fully acknowledge the importance of mass media, film in particular, as a powerful site for critical intervention” (hooks 128). The withholding of crucial information until the ending revelation that Inez is not Terry’s biological mother serves as a metaphor for the missing pieces, delegitimized through state violence and government policy, which obstructs a comprehensive picture. What judgment audiences are willing to levy against Inez throughout the film speaks as much to their assumptions as to her character. Capitulation to social and legal norms would have doomed Terry to a motherless childhood within a foster system famous for its neglect. According to New York’s legal framework, as seen through the actions taken by social workers like Ms. Tucker, this would be the only viable path for a boy like Terry. Motherhood is then reduced to a birth certificate and a DNA test— i.e. traditional, lawful heteronormativity. Audiences are left pondering the staggering losses under this framework.
Bibliography
- Alexander, Michelle. The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness. New York, The New Press, 2012, Pg. 57-63.
- Gledhill, Christine. Home is Where the Heart Is: Studies in Melodrama and Women’s Film. London, BFI Publishing, 1987, Pg. 21.
- hooks, bell. “The Oppositional Gaze: Black Female Spectators.” Black Looks: Race and Representation. Boston, New End Press, 1992, Pgs. 115-132.
- hooks, bell. “Homeplace: A Site of Resistance.” Yearning: Race, Gender, and Cultural Politics. Routledge, New York, 2015. Pg. 41-49.
















































